>Users:   login   |  register       > email     > people    


Notes from the Field: Evidence-Based Practice Research as Responsible Practice
By John Wetzel, National Institute of Justice
Published: 03/11/2019

Prison wall a

It sounds embarrassingly simple: Stop doing things that don’t work and do more of the things that do. Yet we blindly pour millions of dollars into corrections programs and practices without demanding improved outcomes like reduced violence or recidivism. When you consider the stakes of corrections work and the sheer volume of the lives we impact, I see basing decisions and policies on research as the only means to go about responsible practice.

At the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, research has become part of the fiber of who we are as an organization. In 2014 we began a long-term partnership with New York University’s BetaGov, which supports practitioner-led research in the public sector. This partnership has been key for scaling research within our organization. With BetaGov, we have completed and published more than three dozen trials, with hundreds more studies still in progress.

Promoting Trial, Celebrating Error

The only way to improve outcomes is to try something, measure it, and scale it if evaluation shows that it is promising. If it’s not effective, we figure out why, adjust, and try again. A study that shows absent or negative effects isn’t a failure — we learn as much from these studies as we do from studies that show what does work. When we saw mixed outcomes from the research trial of an in-prison swift, certain, and fair (SCF) program, it forced us to look at the policy and design to understand why. We’re now adapting a more consistent policy that builds on strengths in areas of the program that showed positive outcomes.

In Pennsylvania we still struggle with drugs coming into our facilities, and we have tested various ways to curb this problem. We experimented with sending letters to family members to warn them of the consequences of bringing drugs into our facilities. It sounded like a good idea and I thought it would work. But when we measured outcomes, the data told us that the letters didn’t have a positive impact on drugs in our facilities — we actually saw a slight increase in drugs after this trial. Given this result, we won’t waste money on that program. Along a similar vein of experimenting, we tried a new approach to drug interdiction that involved phone monitoring and led to the biggest drug bust in the history of the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections.

Keeping an Open Mind

In Pennsylvania, we’ve been willing to study everything. We did a study on aromatherapy in restrictive housing units. I thought this study was ridiculous, but the data told us that aromatherapy does reduce violent incidents, and it’s cheap, so this is something we’re taking to scale. Another study with results that surprised me involved providing more colorful bed linens for inmates. We seem to enjoy especially good outcomes in trials where we’ve introduced additional choice to inmates.

Many of the ideas for studies we carry out come from our line staff. I spent nine years of my career as a corrections officer, but sitting at the top of an 18,000-person agency, it can be difficult to see the on-the-ground implications of policies and protocols. In conducting research, it’s been important to find and implement a mechanism to consistently get input from line staff in a way that is meaningful and measureable. If there’s a complicated problem that we have to solve as an organization, we involve as many staff as we can in the solution. Directors of departments of correction come and go, but ideas with agency-wide buy-in will stay.

Iterate With Inertia

Our research partnership with BetaGov has taught us the importance of rapid iteration. We need to not only employ measurement and iteration, but do this within as short a timeframe as possible. Beginning in 2011, our department made transformational and expansive policy changes over an 18-month period, sparked by a Department of Justice investigation into our use of restrictive housing. In implementing these rapid changes, we developed a greater sense of urgency around conducting research to inform how we do business. This inertia is important. Long bureaucratic timeframes can kill staff enthusiasm and innovative ideas. Without timely turnaround, we lose momentum and enthusiasm, and a study’s results become less relevant.

Corrections isn’t a field known for being agile or receptive to change. Directors of state departments of corrections are always going to face resistance to change. But given high rates of violence in our facilities and recidivism after release, I see the status quo as much more dangerous than trying new things. I’m often asked how Pennsylvania has been able to engrain research into the way we do business, but I don’t know how we could not do anything without measuring it and adjusting it based on the outcomes. I’m shocked by the notion that we would do anything without trying to maximize efficiency, safety, and effectiveness both within our facilities and as inmates reintegrate into their communities. Within our department, research, evaluation, and rapid iteration have become part of our institutional fabric and how we relate to the world.

About “Notes from the Field”

The National Institute of Justice (NIJ) is the research, development, and evaluation arm of the U.S. Department of Justice. NIJ aims to address the critical questions of the criminal justice field, particularly at the state and local levels.

NIJ Director David Muhlhausen developed the “Notes from the Field” series to allow leading voices in the field to share their strategies for responding to the most pressing issues on America’s streets today.

“Notes from the Field” is not a research-based publication. Instead, it presents lessons learned by law enforcement executives and other on-the-ground leaders, from years of experience and thinking deeply about law enforcement issues.

About the Author

John Wetzel, widely recognized as one of the thought leaders in corrections today, was appointed secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections in January 2011 by Governor Corbett and reappointed by Governor Wolf in January 2015. During his tenure an elimination of a 24-year average growth of 1500 inmates per year occurred. Wetzel presided over the first population reduction in the Pennsylvania state prison system in over 4 decades, a restructuring of the community corrections and mental health systems, and a re-engineering of internal processes to yield a more efficient system of program delivery. With over 29 years of experience in the corrections field, he has been selected as chair of the Council of State Governments’ Justice Center’s Executive Board and as president of the Association of State Correctional Administrators. He is a member of Harvard’s Executive Session on Community Corrections. A graduate of Bloomsburg University, he received honorary doctor of laws degrees from the Indiana University of Pennsylvania in May 2016 and Chestnut Hill College in May 2018.

Writing and editorial support was provided by Rianna P. Starheim, a writer with a federal contractor, on assignment at the National Institute of Justice, U.S. Department of Justice.


Comments:

  1. irby2011 on 07/17/2019:

    I really appreciate your effort in providing a wonderful and amazing precious metals ira blog to us.

  2. p10olo12 on 07/16/2019:

    Great post and very insightful information. I am really happy to visit and read your fantastic post. ketogenic diet

  3. jac0b978 on 07/10/2019:

    Great how to get a hot girl article! It is great to visit and read your blog. Look forward to seeing and listening to you!

  4. l4yla143 on 07/05/2019:

    I have bookmarked your site and I am looking forward to reading new articles from you in the future. Graco all in one car seat

  5. nkkiez on 07/04/2019:

    You created a fantastic and extraordinary ideas and data here ulcerative colitis symptoms

  6. eth4n0hara on 06/30/2019:

    Its constantly nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained. tax business marketing

  7. susank on 06/20/2019:

    Wonderful website and this is very superb data to find out alcohol and drug services auckland

  8. jssaknt on 06/19/2019:

    Thank you for establishing this is magnficent website. I happy to seen this topic buy chicken egg cartons

  9. digitinc on 06/15/2019:

    Beer Delivery Near Me Alcohol Delivery Services is one of the best local Alcohol takeaway in London. We pride ourselves in the fact that we serve delicious traditional and contemporary Alcohol cuisine to take away and enjoy in the comfort of your own home. Our services Deliver is a platform that will allow you to have anything in your city to be delivered directly to your door come day or night. You can now order your drinks online your order will be delivered to your home, office, function or any other occasion.

  10. gr3tchen3 on 06/13/2019:

    This great cbd for ulcerative colitis symptoms post. Really a very nice and useful piece of information.

  11. justin obama on 06/10/2019:

    This is chopping down the post. I like this topic. This site has stores of advantage. I found unmistakable confounding things on this site. anker promo code, kindle coupon, active target promo codes, relapse records discount code, zinus mattress promo code amazon, chi coupons, Fitbit coupons, Hot Tools coupon code, ac/dc coupon, Allegra K Coupon, bing promo code, lucid mattress coupon, expression tees discount code, beachwaver discount code, rock and roll cowgirl coupon code, salty crew discount code, Drive Medical coupon, Flashforge coupon Code, It interfaces with me in various ways.

  12. j4ckdav1s5 on 05/28/2019:

    gold ira opportunities I’ve taken your advice, thank you and please keep up the good work.

  13. nkkiez on 05/26/2019:

    This is a highly beneficial weblog! I'm highly contented this is outstanding ideas to provided to us ulcerative colitis in children

  14. j4s0n0707 on 05/23/2019:

    Graco convertible car seat I am grateful that I have read your amazing article. I am looking forward to your more post about this topic.

  15. lou1s5w1ley on 05/22/2019:

    You always share interesting and informational articles and that’s why I love visiting your blog over and over again. Thanks for the free share. shopping for your keto diet

  16. prepaidgiftbalance on 05/20/2019:

    https://prepaidgiftbalanceinfo.online/ https://prepaidgiftbalanceinfo.online/mygiftcardsite/ https://prepaidgiftbalanceinfo.online/prepaidcardstatus-login-online-at-www-prepaidcardstatus-com/ https://prepaidgiftbalanceinfo.online/mybalancenow-check-target-gift-card-balance-at-www-mybalancenow-com/

  17. Daniel Lee on 05/14/2019:

    Good work and keep it up thanks. [url="http://example.org"]Example[/url] [url=http://example.org]Example[/url] Example [url]http://example.org[/url] [Link](http://google.com)

  18. joshuaprice153 on 04/25/2019:

    Last time I visited there's just a couple of posts with very few reader feedback and now this place is just crowded! Way to go man. Nice article, btw ;) Orlando Paint Solutions

  19. ted1987 on 04/22/2019:

    I commend your hard work on this and thank you for this information 192.168.l.l

  20. deena on 04/19/2019:

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts and ideas on this one. Please keep posting about such Bradley Cooper Jacket articles as they really spread useful information.

  21. deena on 04/19/2019:

    Its my great pleasure to visit your blog and to enjoy your great posts here. I like it a lot. I can feel that you paid much attention for those articles, as all of them make sense and Doctor sami are very useful.

  22. deena on 04/19/2019:

    yes I appreciate your question & this idea. The idea makes it easy for the public to approach a valid resources for solving their problem. I have a business of mens Coats and Jackets Collectionfor the business men & salaried person public can find efficientseriesblog.comt this idea helpful for their life.

  23. deena on 04/19/2019:

    The excellently written article, if not all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be much better placed. Really great post, Thank you for sharing this knowledge. Get much more The Shopping Store Jacket well in simple one click

  24. Jacqueline Fernand on 04/18/2019:

    An American TV star, who is a rapper and on-screen character, is formally known as Vanilla Ice, while his genuine name is Robert Matthew Van Winkle. Vanilla Ice discharged his introduction collection under the name of 'Snared' in 1989 and turned into an effective rap star. Robert Matthew Vanilla Ice Jacket

  25. stevelarsc on 04/17/2019:

    It is time we should find more effective ideas to educate people about the negative sides of drug usage. The efforts done by you guys in pensilvania to reduce the drug usage had been exceptionally appreciable. lip injections near me We hope thee continous efforts wil surely help you find a better way to control this disaster.

  26. run3 on 04/16/2019:

    Notes from the scene are very detailed and meticulous. with lots of interesting and interesting information. fnaf world

  27. lewis on 04/12/2019:

    NJMCDirect allows you to use a Prefix Code with which you can pay your ticket fines online through its portal. NJMCDirect is a fast, secure, convenient way to access your traffic ticket information online. mybkexperience | njmcdirect | upsers

  28. josefsmith304 on 03/19/2019:

    I've read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this $200 bing ads coupon article. I want to read more things about it!

  29. DannyPowell on 03/13/2019:

    Research and analysis are integral parts of a process that is aimed at improving something! Research in a particular area requires the provision of a written result on paper that each researcher or analyst can learn to do on his or her own if he or she practices writing papers using the site https://samples.edusson.com/ which contains many examples of essay that have different topics! Research also requires a report on the data: how much time was spent on research, how many people participated in the research, and how much money was spent on research!


Login to let us know what you think

User Name:   

Password:       


Forgot password?





correctsource logo




Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of The Corrections Connection User Agreement
The Corrections Connection ©. Copyright 1996 - 2019 © . All Rights Reserved | 15 Mill Wharf Plaza Scituate Mass. 02066 (617) 471 4445 Fax: (617) 608 9015